The effect of exchange rate movements on trade balance. New marshalllerner conditions for an economy with outward. The marshalllerner condition refers to the impact of a depreciation, or devaluation, of a currency on the current account of the balance of payments. It is named after the three economists who discovered it independently. In particular, we use quarterly data on the log of real exchange rates, exportimport ratio and relative us income for the time period 1996q1. Using the url or doi link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. The marshall lerner condition is satisfied for india as. The validity of marshalllerner condition in turkey. In particular, we use quarterly data on the log of real exchange rates, exportimport ratio and relative us income for the time period 1996q1 2011q4, and employ techniques based on the concept of long memory or longrange. Marshalllerner financial definition of marshalllerner. According to the marshalllerner condition, the sum of trade elasticities should be greater than one for a change in exchange rate to have an impact on the.
Apr 27, 2012 the marshall lerner condition when evaluating the impact of a currency fluctuation on the balance of trade we should consider the marshall lerner condition. This has the effect of shifting the nx curve from nx1 to nx2. Marshalllerner condition and the balance of payments. Jul 12, 2001 a typical finding in the empirical literature is that import and export demand elasticities are rather low, and that the marshalllerner ml condition does not hold. In particular, we use quarterly data on the log of real exchange rates, exportimport ratio and. The international debate about trade imbalances often puts the focus on the role of domestic gdpforeign gdp and the role of real exchange rate changes with respect to the latter adjustment channel, the standard question is whether or not the marshalllerner condition is fulfilled. The marshalllerner condition after alfred marshall and abba p. Results of the study indicate that marshall lerner condition does hold in the long run for pakistan but not in the short run, thus supporting the phenomenon of jcurve. Here are two videos from jason welker which give an indepth look at the theory of the marshalllerner condition and the j curve. Examining exchange rates exposure, jcurve and the marshalllerner condition for high frequency trade series between china and malaysia. Mathematical proof of the marshall lerner condition. In this paper we examine the marshalllerner ml condition for the kenyan economy. M are the demand elasticities for a countrys exports and imports respectively, both defined to be positive for downward sloping demands.
Nevertheless, it was named after alfred marshall who was born in 1842 and died in 1924, since he is considered as the father of the elasticity as a concept and lerner 15 for his later. The marshalllerner condition by behzad jahanzad on prezi. Marshalllerner condition is wrong by hak choi ssrn. The main contribution of this paper is that it tests for and incorporates nonlinearity into the balance of trade equation of boyd, caporale, and smith 2001. The marshalllerner condition also called the marshalllernerrobinson, hereafter, mlr, condition is at the heart of the elasticities approach to the balance of payments. Nevertheless, the marshalllerner condition is satisfied only for canada, south korea and the us. This paper develops an analytical reformulation of the marshall lerner condition. L condition, which stipulates that a devaluation or depreciation of its currency will improve a countrys trade balance only if the sum of the absolute values of a countrys import and export price elasticities are greater than one, is a fundamental tenet of international economics. Given that the marshall lerner condition is holding, it implies that the value of exports will be less than the product of the quantity of imports and the import bill, thus making the value of imports in terms of domestic goods to be greater than the value of exports. Testing the marshalllerner condition in kenya core.
Marshalllerner condition plural marshalllerner conditions the condition that an exchange rate devaluation or depreciation will only cause a balance of trade improvement if the absolute sum of the long run export and import demand elasticities is equal to, or greater than 1. One may derive a range for the elasticity of the ratio of exports to imports with respect to the real exchange rate, namely that the sum of the absolute import elasticities. Marshall lerner condition plural marshall lerner conditions economics the condition that an exchange rate devaluation or depreciation will only cause a balance of trade improvement if the absolute sum of the long run export and import demand elasticities is equal to, or greater than 1. The standard model of trade and the marshall lerner condition. After this idea was introduced, many included me had the. Testing the marshalllernerrobinson condition in ghana. Marshalllerner condition in international trade, a theory stating that if the sum of price elasticity of a countrys exports and the price elasticity of its imports is greater than one, a devaluation of that countrys currency will improve its balance of trade. Testing for marshalllerner condition forman christian college. The marshalllerner condition is a precise statement of this. Pdf marshalllerner ml condition is a phenomenon that describes increase in net exports through depreciation of.
Marshalllerner condition financial definition of marshall. The marshalllerner condition effects of changes in exchange rates does price elasticity matter. When a currency appreciates we normally assume exports fall and imports increase. Devaluation does not improve the balance of trade if the sum is any lower. The idea underlying the marshalllerner condition is that demand for imports and exports must be sufficiently pricesensitive so that an increase in the relative price of imports increases the difference between export receipts and import expenditures. It is named after the economists who discovered it independently. While recent trade literature has focused on exchange rate passthrough the role of. Download pdf 215 kb abstract the analysis considers the impact of fdi inflows and fdi outflows and shows that the presence of cumulated fdi requires higher import elasticities in absolute terms than stated in the standard marshall lerner condition. Trade elasticities and the marshal lerner condition for india. When my class and i try to test the marshall lerner condition it doesnt always work. Mar 26, 2011 the analysis considers the impact of fdi inflows and fdi outflows and shows that the presence of cumulated fdi requires higher import elasticities in absolute terms than stated in the standard marshall lerner condition. The marshalllerner condition is satisfied if the absolute sum of a countrys export and import. Testing the marshalllerner condition in kenya caporale.
We find support for the marshall lerner condition in four industries. The pessimism in foreign trade elasticities is the reverse side of the optimism in revaluation. This paper develops an analytical reformulation of the marshalllerner condition. Marshalllerner condition is a further extension of the elasticities approach. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Nevertheless, the marshall lerner condition is satisfied only for canada, south korea and the us. We normally assume that when a currency depreciates imports fall and exports increase and therefore balance of trade improves. It is important to consider the price elasticity of demand for exports and imports when investigating the impact currency devaluation has on the balance of payments, an accounting. Lerner is satisfied if the absolute sum of a countrys export and import demand elasticities demand responsiveness to price is greater than one. Almost all previous studies estimated the condition using aggregate trade data. This paper examines the marshall lerner condition for the six bilateral trade balances between the u. This reformation of the marshall lerner condition leads us to reformulate both the thirwal.
The marshall lerner condition states that for a devaluation of domestic currency to improve the balance of payments, the sum of the price elasticities of demand for exports and imports must be greater than one. By examining the existence of lr relationship between the exchange rate and netexports. This is the period prior to the first of a series of currency devaluations and structural. Domestic and foreign incomes are significant and correctly signed. The wellknown marshalllerner condition states that a real exchange rate appreciation termsoftrade improvement, i. Revisiting the marshalllerner condition under processing.
Pdf on may 1, 2018, ilyas siklar and others published estimation of the marshalllerner condition and j curve dynamics for turkey find. Why have many economics teachers misunderstood the marshall. The marshall lerner condition is introduced in the a2 the global economy course, which states that if the sum of the elasticity of demand for imports and exports is greater than one, a currency devaluation will lead to an improvement in the balance of payments. A new group is now emerging which uses data at commodity level to reduce aggregation bias. The marshalllerner condition, named after british economist alfred marshall 18421924 and american economist abba lerner 190382, is an often asserted economic statement that specifies the circumstances under which a downward movement of the exchange rate, arising from either marketdetermined depreciation or monetary authority devaluation, will exert a favorable influence on a nation. Pdf estimation of the marshalllerner condition and j curve. The condition could be seen as an implication of the work of bickerdike 18. The marshalllerner condition, named after british economist alfred marshall 18421924 and american economist abba lerner 190382, is an often asserted economic statement that specifies the circumstances under which a downward movement of the exchange rate, arising from either marketdetermined depreciation or monetary authority devaluation, will exert a. The purpose of this study is to survey the literature that has. A modified marshalllerner condition under processing trade. The aim of the paper is to test the marshalllernerrobinson condition by using the unitroot test of ngperron 2001 and cointegration test of perronrodriguez 2001.
The time period of interest in this study is 19601983. One may derive a range for the elasticity of the ratio of exports to imports with respect to the real exchange rate, namely that the sum of the absolute. Nov 20, 2018 testing marshall lerner condition 20 november 2018 8 january 2008 by tejvan pettinger readers question. Our empirical findings reveal that the marshalllerner condition holds that real depreciation accelerates trade expansion in the long run but only the short run import demands adhere to the potential jcurve pattern. Effects of currency depreciation includes marshall lerner condition the condition states that, provided that the sum of the price elasticity of demand coefficients for exports and imports is greater than one then a fall in the exchange rate will reduce a deficit and a rise will reduce a surplus.
The marshall lerner condition is a precise statement of this. Why have many economics teachers misunderstood the. New marshalllerner conditions for an economy with outward and. This article will be of particular interest to teachers of the intermediate course in international economics. Nov 10, 2011 this video explains the marshall lerner condition for determining whether a depreciation of a nations currency will improve or worsen its current account balance. Testing marshall lerner condition 20 november 2018 8 january 2008 by tejvan pettinger readers question. Apr 05, 2020 download article as pdf july 2018, paperii question let the elasticity of demand for exports for a certain country be ex and elasticity of demand for imports be em. Paradoxical comparative statics results follow naturally for the stable equilibrium, while they all. It provides a technique for teaching the effect of devaluation on a countrys trade balance in a simplified way without dilution of substance. Marshalllerner condition and economic globalization. The marshalllerner condition when evaluating the impact of a currency fluctuation on the balance of trade we should consider the marshalllerner condition. Clearly label all curves and explain the dynamics from the initial to the final equilibrium point.
Effects of currency depreciation includes marshall lerner condition effects of a currency depreciation youtube. However, despite the evidence against the ml condition, the consensus is that real devaluations do improve the balance of trade, though after a lag because of j. Marshalllerner condition and economic globalization core. Testing the marshalllerner condition between the u. This reformation of the marshalllerner condition leads us to reformulate both the thirwal. Marshalllerner condition and the balance of payments constrained growth. Marshall lerner condition the price elasticity of demand for imports and exports condition that must be satisfied if an exchangerate alteration devaluation or revaluation is to be successful in removing a balance of payments deficit or surplus.
Hepaktan 2009 investigated marshalllerner condition in turkey through cointegration method by using data of 19802008 period and concluded that this condition does not work accurately. When a currency appreciates we normally assume exports fall and imports increase and thus. Mathematical proof of the marshall lerner condition warwick. The marshall lerner condition refers to the impact of a depreciation, or devaluation, of a currency on the current account of the balance of payments. The condition was proposed by alfred marshall and abba lerner. Exchange rates marshall lerner condition economics. Estimation of the marshalllerner condition for namibia. Exchange rates marshall lerner condition economics tutor2u. Download article as pdf july 2018, paperii question let the elasticity of demand for exports for a certain country be ex and elasticity of demand for imports be em. The marshall lerner condition is at the heart of the elasticities approach to the balance of payments. The marshalllerner condition and exchange market stability. Mar 26, 2015 mathematical proof of the marshall lerner condition the marshall lerner condition is introduced in the a2 the global economy course, which states that if the sum of the elasticity of demand for imports and exports is greater than one, a currency devaluation will lead to an improvement in the balance of payments. Sep 10, 2019 the international debate about trade imbalances often puts the focus on the role of domestic gdpforeign gdp and the role of real exchange rate changes with respect to the latter adjustment channel, the standard question is whether or not the marshalllerner condition is fulfilled.
Alfred marshall 18421924, abba lerner 190382 and joan robinson 190383. Pdf estimation of the marshalllerner condition and j. Marshalllerner condition devaluation economics online. This paper examines the marshalllerner condition for the six bilateral trade balances between the u. These tests are based on procedures for removing the trend using the gls, leading to remove nostochastic components.
We add to this latter group by estimating the marshall lerner condition using commodity prices from 10 single digit industries that trade between korea and the u. Some of the assumptions for the marshall lerner condition to hold. A typical finding in the empirical literature is that import and export demand elasticities are rather low, and that the marshalllerner ml condition does not hold. Testing the marshalllerner condition and the jcurve. The marshalllerner condition reconsidered sciencedirect. Testing the marshalllernerrobinson condition in ghana prior. Define the nominal exchange rate as the units of foreign currency per unit of the domestic currency. Jcurve is a phenomena which has been derived partially from the studies of alfred marshall and abba lerner, which gives it its name marshall lerner condition in the situation where the balance of trade of a country is zero then elasticity in supply are never ending then an exchange rate decrease in value can initiate a surplus surge in the. The marshalllerner condition states that a depreciation of domestic currency can improve a countrys balance of payments only when the sum of the demand elasticity of exports and the demand elasticity of imports exceeds unity. Examining exchange rates exposure, jcurve and the marshall. Choi, hak, marshalllerner condition is wrong october 20, 2012. Marshall lerner robinson condition, estimated by the imperfect substitutes model to forecast the effect of a currency depreciation in 1983 on the trade balance in ghana. Results of the study indicate that marshalllerner condition does hold in the long run for pakistan but not in the short run, thus supporting the phenomenon of jcurve. Lecture notes 6 real exchange rates and the trade balance.
The marshalllerner condition, which states that a currency devaluation will only lead to an improvement in the balance of payments if the sum of demand elasticity for imports and exports is greater than one, is named after english economist alfred marshall 18421924 and the romanian born economist abba lerner 1905 1985. When my class and i try to test the marshalllerner condition it doesnt always work. The marshall lerner condition shows the conditions under which a change in the exchange rate of a countrys currency leads to an improvement or worsening of a countrys balance of payments. Further a 1% increase in domestic income increases indias imports by 0. The marshall lerner condition also called the marshall lerner robinson, hereafter, mlr, condition is at the heart of the elasticities approach to the balance of payments. A fall in the exchange rate will increase the price of imports in domestic currency which will lead to a decrease in the quantity demanded. Real exchange rate effects on the balance of trade. The condition that the sum of the elasticities of demand for exports and imports exceed one in absolute value. For the analytically rather transparent case of asymmetric outward fdi, a new marshalllerner condition can be derived. The condition states that the current account will improve, after a depreciation, if the sum of the price elasticities of demand for imports and exports is greater than 1. The marshalllerner condition is an important condition that determines whether or not a exchange rate depreciation will cause the balance of trade to improve or to deteriorate. This video explains the marshalllerner condition for determining whether a depreciation of a nations currency will improve or worsen its current account balance.
It should serve to bring the marshalllerner condition out of the appendix and into the. Marshalllernerrobinson condition, estimated by the imperfect substitutes model to forecast the effect of a currency depreciation in 1983 on the trade balance in ghana. But it is found that the absolute sum of imports and exports price elasticities of demand barely exceed 1, indicating that a real devaluation of rupee will only. The analysis considers the impact of fdi inflows and fdi outflows and shows that the presence of cumulated fdi requires higher import elasticities in absolute terms than stated in the standard marshall lerner condition. The marshalllerner condition is at the heart of the elasticities approach to the balance of payments. Marshalllerner condition apple b ugc net jrf academy. The marshalllerner condition states that for a devaluation of domestic currency to improve the balance of payments, the sum of the price elasticities of demand for exports and imports must be greater than one. While recent trade literature has focused on exchange rate passthrough the role of fdi has not been much. The marshalllerner condition asserts that a devaluation or depreciation will improve the trade balance if sum of price elasticities of import and export demand exceeds unity.
1181 1358 1329 693 193 1547 961 13 717 796 521 1311 766 1393 1354 1285 1017 102 348 155 955 1412 954 427 35 266 1263 174 1283 514 1485 870 315 134 57 54 872